Linking Institutions, Security and Pro-Poor Growth in Nigeria

RESEARCH QUESTION

The project's key concerns cluster around three main research foci.  All of these address the conditions under which individuals are more likely to invest in public goods and in entrepreneurial or other investment activities, which are necessary for sustained economic growth. Though data will be collected at the individual level, the project is interested in leveraging how context and, especially, past state and donor interventions affect individual decision-making and economic behaviour. 

PROJECT

Policing, security, and investment.  The project will examine how differences in personal security affect individuals' willingness to invest in public goods, in risky or deferred-payout business investments, or in collaborative business ventures.  Insecurity can be conceived of in different ways.  At the most basic, we would expect that individuals who live in high-crime areas, or areas that have experienced political violence, would feel less secure than those with higher levels of personal security.  However, perceptions of security are also likely to be affected by the quality of policing and state institutions in particular areas.  We are particularly interested in whether community policing reforms, some of which have been funded by DFID, have improved citizens' perceptions of personal security and their orientations toward investment and state institutions.

Tax and political accountability.  The project will examine the relationship between services provision, institutional trust, and citizens' willingness to pay taxes.  The underlying question at work here is whether visible reduction in corruption and improvement in government performance can quickly shift citizens' orientation to the state.  State policy interventions are likely to be less effective where ties of accountability between governments and citizens are underdeveloped.  This aspect of the project therefore attempts to get at the conditions under which cooperative or consensual exchanges between governments and citizens are more possible.

Politics, identity and investment.  The final component of the research addresses how other political concerns affect risk-averseness and attitudes toward investment.  Our intuition is that areas with higher levels of communal polarization or party competition may be seen as less favourable investment climates.  This component of the research addresses whether improvements in election monitoring, communal relations, or demonetarization of electoral contestation might improve citizens' willingness to invest, pay taxes, or undertake other actions that would enhance prospects for growth.  We also seek to establish a baseline regarding how Nigerians see the current investment climate versus their retrospective evaluation of investment climate during the last administration.  We are particularly interested in whether perception of improvement or decline differs across states and across economic classes within states.

Pilot
In order to test the wording and focus of our questionnaire we will begin by conducting a pilot survey of 600 respondents.  The pilot will be carried out in Lagos state in July 2010, which has undertaken substantial reform of tax collection in the past years, as well as a significant expansion of infrastructure development and social services provision.  The pilot will be used as a test and plausibility probe for our questionnaire and two survey-embedded experimental instruments.  In the second phase, we will then investigate whether Lagos findings can be generalized to Nigeria as a whole.

Main survey
While the main survey will clearly need to be reshaped in-line with the outcome of the pilot, we envisage a sample size of 3,000 respondents across 10 locations in 5 states during December 2010.  This will allow us to leverage difference within states and between states, and to assess the impact of international interventions and variations in the quality of state government and local demographic factors.  We plan to draw on past donor and state reform initiatives in order to select research sites.

RESEARCHERS

Etannibi Alemika

CLEEN Foundation, Nigeria

Nic Cheeseman

University of Oxford

Adrienne LeBas

American University

OUTPUT

Governing Lagos: Unlocking the Politics of Reform

Diane de Gramont

Carnegie Endowment for International Peace Working Paper, January 2015

Beyond Magic Bullets in Governance Reform

Diane de Gramont

Carnegie Paper, 4 Nov 2014
 

The Origins of Voluntary Compliance: Attitudes toward Taxation in Urban Nigeria

Cristina Bodea and Adrienne Lebas

British Journal of Political Science, Cambridge University Press Sep 2014

Taxation and Accountability in Lagos: Presentation to the Lagos State Government, Panel Survey Part 1

Nic Cheeseman

Presented by Nic Cheeseman at Lagos State Government Cabinet Meeting, to Governor and Commissioners, 29 Oct 2013

Taxation and Accountability in Lagos: Presentation to the Lagos State Government, Panel Survey Part 2

Nic Cheeseman

Presented by Nic Cheeseman at Lagos State Government Cabinet Meeting, to Governor and Commissioners, 15 Dec 2013

Taxation and Accountability in Lagos: Presentation to the Lagos State Government, Panel Survey Part 3

Nic Cheeseman

Presented by Nic Cheeseman at Lagos State Government Cabinet Meeting, to Governor and Commissioners, 22 Jul 2014

Encouraging tax compliance in the informal sector

iiG Briefing Paper 24, May 2013

Violence and Urban Order in Nairobi, Kenya, and Lagos, Nigeria

Adrienne LeBas

Studies in Comparative and International Development  48:3, July 2013

Ethnopopulism in Africa: opposition mobilization in diverse and unequal societies

Nic Cheeseman and Miles Larmer

Democratization, Vol. 22 (1), pp. 22-50, 2013

The Origins of Social Contracts: Attitudes toward Taxation in Urban Nigeria

Cristina Bodea and Adrienne LeBas

CSAE Working Paper WPS/2013-02, Jan 2013

Attitudes towards citizenship in Nigeria

iiG Briefing Paper 22, December 2012

Do the Nigerian public trust their police?

iiG Briefing Paper 21, December 2012

Building the Social Contract: Taxation in Urban Nigeria

Cristina Bodea and Adrienne LeBas

Presented at iiG workshop "Improving revenue generation through taxation in Nigeria", 9th October 2012. Abuja, Nigeria

Raising revenue to reduce poverty

iiG Briefing Paper 16, October 2011

The consequences of crime

iiG Briefing Paper 15, October 2011

Power-sharing in comparative perspective: the dynamics of 'unity government' in Kenya and Zimbabwe

Nic Cheeseman and Blessing-Miles Tendi

The Journal of Modern African Studies, Vol. 48 (02), pp. 203-29, 2010

Improving revenue generation through taxation in Nigeria

iiG Workshop

Abuja, Nigeria, 9 October 2012

OReNGA Special Lecture

Babatunde Fashola, Governor of Lagos State, Nigeria

Rhodes House, University of Oxford, 7 October 2011

Researching Nigeria

iiG Workshop

African Studies Centre, University of Oxford, June 2010